F1 Broadcast Faces Harsh Backlash Over Race 'Protagonist' Role

LISTEN

0:00 0:00

Highlights

Fernando Alonso criticizes Formula 1 team radio broadcasts.
He calls selective radio clips “poorly chosen” and “unnecessary.”
Alonso says team radios often lack listener context and clarity.
He warns frequent radio use overshadows actual racing action.
Comments made ahead of the 2025 United States Grand Prix.
Alonso urges improved balance between radio chatter and race focus.

Fernando Alonso criticises Formula 1’s team-radio broadcasting, warning selective clips skew narratives. He speaks ahead of the 2025 United States Grand Prix, urging more context and restraint.

He calls several broadcasts “poorly chosen” and “unnecessary,” citing frustration after Singapore, where his irritated message aired without the surrounding discussion.

Alonso: selective radio clips are “poorly chosen” and “unnecessary.”

Alonso notes most exchanges are routine and strategic. Teams and drivers revisit pre-planned scenarios, tyre offsets, and contingencies, not dramatic outbursts.

Editing radio into short soundbites strips intent and timing, he argues. Viewers can misread tone, strategy triggers, or context like traffic, temperatures, or management targets.

He adds that when radio becomes “the protagonist,” it often signals thin on‑track action. That shift, he says, reflects a broadcast scrambling for narrative.

Radio can become “the protagonist of the race” when action is thin.

F1’s rights holder curates a large volume of team audio. Clips are selected and timed for television, which places significant responsibility on editorial judgement and context.

Used well, radio enriches coverage. It reveals strategy pivots, car limitations, and pressure points. But it works best alongside graphics, timing info, and clear explanation.

Alonso shares the stage with Ollie Bearman and Franco Colapinto, who also discuss cockpit comms. The thread underscores differing tolerances for broadcast intrusion during races.

He urges a better balance between cockpit communications and on‑track storytelling.

Teams treat radio as public by default, yet expect proportional use. Drivers adapt their language, while engineers manage sensitivity without compromising operational clarity.

The narrative matters as title and podium battles evolve. Broadcast emphasis can colour perceptions of McLaren, Red Bull, and Ferrari duels involving Piastri, Norris, Verstappen, and Hamilton.

With races ahead in Mexico City, Brazil, Las Vegas, and Qatar, the balance between access and clarity will shape how fans experience decisive stints and strategy windows.

Alonso’s message is straightforward. Keep radio, but sharpen selection and context. Let the wheel‑to‑wheel action lead, with comms supporting rather than steering the story.